The item was added to shopping cart
Back To Top

Nostalgic Candy

1 - 12 of 72 Found
View
Sort by:
  1. Bit-O-Honey Candy - 19 oz.
    Description

    Bit-O-Honey candy is loved for its sweet, chewy goodness. These old time candy treats take you back to simpler days, when a good piece of candy lasted a good, long time. Bit-O-Honey features real almond bits blended into honey-flavored taffy. Set of two 9.5 oz. bags.

    Bit-O-Honey Candy - 19 oz.

    bc00404571

    (0)

    $13.98
  2. Squirrel Nut Zippers® Candy
    Description

    …these chewy, Squirrel Nut Zippers® candies were scooped up in handfuls at penny-candy counters, while kids spent allowances to fill their pockets with the yummy treasures. Just as soft and delicious as they were back in 1926, the creamy, nutty, squirrel nut candies bring back memories of sweet,…

    Squirrel Nut Zippers® Candy

    bc00343807

    (0)

    $6.99
  3. Tootsie Roll Midgees®
    Description

    …a sweet, never-sticky taffy treat. The top-selling chocolate taffy candy in America, Tootsie Rolls are still made with the original recipe from 1896, and still the best. The ultimate trick-or-treat treasure and star of any candy dish, they’re individually wrapped and sure to disappear quickly! 9.5…

    Tootsie Roll Midgees®

    bc00392170

    (2)

    $6.99
  4. Mrs. Kimball’s Nostalgic Mix Refill
    Description

    Brimming with penny candy favorites from your past, Mrs. Kimball’s nostalgic mix refill will make you feel like a kid in a candy shop again! The nostalgic candy mix includes Banana Split Chews, Bit-O-Honey, Tootsie Roll, Goetze Caramel Creams and Dad’s Root Beer Barrels—all individually wrapped.…

    Mrs. Kimball’s Nostalgic Mix Refill

    bc00400348

    (0)

    $6.99
  5. Mrs. Kimball’s Candy Shoppe Nostalgic Candy Mix Keepsake Tin
    Description

    Brimming with penny candy favorites from your past, Mrs. Kimball’s Candy Shoppe Nostalgic Candy Mix Keepsake Tin will make you feel like a kid in a candy shop again! The assorted candy mix includes Banana Split Chews, Bit-O-Honey, Tootsie Roll, Goetze Caramel Creams and Dad’s Root Beer Barrels—all…

    Mrs. Kimball’s Candy Shoppe Nostalgic Candy Mix Keepsake Tin

    bc00400272

    (0)

    $12.99
  6. Atomic Fireballs™
    Description

    …Fireballs™ starts out sweet, then turns up the heat—and leaves you begging for more! With 15 million of this spicy cinnamon candy enjoyed each week, worldwide, the nostalgic classic has been delighting brave fans since 1954. Each long-lasting jawbreaker offers layers of fun, going from sweet to hot,…

    Atomic Fireballs™

    bc00392167

    (4)

    $6.99
  7. Mary Jane®  Refill Candy 10 oz.
    Description

    Delightful as always, Mary Jane® refill candies are still made today with that fresh peanut butter taste and hint of molasses—and kids of all ages still love it! Our old fashioned candy make a sweet, nostalgic gift. 10 oz.

    Mary Jane® Refill Candy 10 oz.

    bc00385862

    (0)

    $6.99
  8. Caramel Apple Creams®
    Description

    …of tart, creamy apple-flavored fondant. Like a crisp granny smith drenched in buttery caramel, the kitchen-fresh caramel apple candies are sweet, tart and spot-on scrumptious. Each individually wrapped caramel candy is nut-free, made in the USA ... and will have you craving an apple a day! 11 oz.

    Caramel Apple Creams®

    bc00390609

    (0)

    $6.99
  9. Old Fashioned Candy Sticks
    Description

    candy sticks in 12 flavors! These timeless Gilliam candy sticks are individually wrapped and bursting with flavors of Peppermint, Sour Apple, Tutti Frutti, Strawberry, Root Beer, Passion Fruit, Peaches and Cream, Lemon, Blueberry, Tangerine, Cinnamon and Watermelon. Old fashioned stick candy is 12…

    Old Fashioned Candy Sticks

    0000145924

    (12)

    $9.99
  10. Necco® Banana Split Candy Chews
    Description

    Like the penny candy you loved as a child, these soft Necco® banana split candy chews have that great banana flavor only Necco® candy can create. Individually wrapped, nostalgic banana candy is simply scrumptious! 10.5 oz.

    Necco® Banana Split Candy Chews

    bc00369873

    (0)

    $6.99
  11. Circus Peanuts
    Description

    This peanut-shaped candy is still as soft and chewy as you remember ... with the pretty orange color and unique banana flavor. A penny candy classic dating back to the 19th century, nostalgic Circus Peanuts are fat free and simply scrumptious. And now you can enjoy all the fun without any…

    Circus Peanuts

    bc00396513

    (1)

    $6.99
  12. Lemonhead Candies
    Description

    …Lemonhead candies. Introduced in 1962 by the Ferrara Candy Company, they’re made with the same cold-panned process as the company’s Red Hots®, boasting real lemon juice for a flavorful punch. Each individually-wrapped lemon candy features a sweet coating, soft sour shell and hard candy core. 12 oz.

    Lemonhead Candies

    bc00392307

    (1)

    $6.99
Powered by Site Search powered by SLI Systems